I loved Ben. I was certain of it. He was tall and strong and handsome and smart and athletic and perfect. He was also a 21-year-old alcoholic and I was a naive 17-year-old. Our relationship was a train-wreck. One with many casualties.
When he loved me, he really loved me. I felt important and beautiful and adored. But when he passive-aggressively made me feel worthless, I believed him and began trying harder to please him. My self-worth was directly tied to how much he loved me. Which he never truly did. That was not his fault.
He was a good guy with a great heart from a great family. But we should have never been together. It never made sense. Our relationship was never easy.
Square peg. Round hole. Every time.
He was too comfortable to break up with me and I was too terrified of losing him to allow it. I'm not sure how many years that dysfunctional relationship would have continued had I not left for college. He wrote one time. I ached for him for years.
Years later we ran into each other at a basketball game and he asked if he could take me to dinner to catch up. His cologne was the same. His hug, familiar. But his words were foreign.
He apologized. For everything.
We talked for hours about where our lives had taken us and how our dreams had shifted since we'd been making them together. I remembered every facial expression and still knew when he was going to laugh before the sound came out. I had memorized so much about him.
When we emerged from the restaurant, the parking lot had frozen over. He asked me if I remembered the night of my senior Christmas Ball when we had "ice skated" through the school parking lot. I did.
He offered me his hands and began to "skate" me around the parking lot. He tightened his grip and began spinning me faster. His hands were so strong. I closed my eyes and remembered exactly why I had chosen to stay with him for so long. He made me feel safe.
And then the spinning stopped. I was light-headed and giggly. He told me I had never looked more beautiful.
I rejected his compliment. I began blabbing on about how my hair was a mess and how he must be mistaken, when he paused me mid-sentence.
"When someone gives you a compliment Amber, you simply say 'Thank you,'" he said. "They wouldn't take the time to say it if they didn't mean it."
I forgave him. For everything.
When he hugged me goodbye, I knew I would never see him again. I didn't need to. Our relationship had come full circle, and to start at the beginning again would be a mistake. He knew it. I knew it. But this time, both of us had the wisdom to walk away.